Remove oranges, lemons, and cinnamon sticks (they will widen) and discard. Please note, I only added the oranges and lemons for the citrus flavor not to press them for the juice.
Take the potato masher and press the apples down to get the juice out
Add the cheese cloth to another bowl making sure the outside drapes the side of the bowl
Add the “pressed” apples to the cheese cloth. The juice will start to come out. Filter again to get all of the juice out
Add the pressed juice back to the crock pot. Discard the apple portions (or save for another project/recipe)
Add 5-6 more cinnamon sticks, 2 tbsp of whole cloves to the crock pot
And the remaining 2 cups of brown sugar and additional water. However- if using alcohol add the entire bottle of dark rum (or less if you're a wimp HA!).
Place on low for 4-5 more hours.
Enjoy hot or cold (but it tastes best hot)